Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Archive for the ‘Regulation’ Category

An excellent National Geographic article describes a new five-year project funded by the Marine Minerals Administration (MMA) to survey the seabed and find better ways to identify archaeological sites hidden beneath it.

That important project warrants public attention. However, what immediately caught my eye was the reference to a prior study by an admired colleague, Dr. Melanie Stright.

Melanie was a leading expert in Gulf of Mexico submerged prehistory and authored important publications that contributed to the field. Her McFaddin Beach research (more below) has been widely cited. Sadly, she died too young in 2011.

In 1994-96, Melanie Stright, an archeologist with the Minerals Management Service (US Dept. of the Interior), began a detailed study of 880 McFaddin Beach artifacts, or about a third of the total known from the site at the time. She examined sources of toolstone, degree of wear, resharpening, the spatial position of the artifact along the beach, ages of the artifacts based on typology, and functional classes of artifacts.

McFaddin Beach, TX

During her last years with MMS, Melanie focused primarily on the proposed CapeWind Energy Project in Nantucket Sound, Massachusetts. She worked to ensure that the comments and concerns of the Native American Tribes were fully considered. During this time, she cultivated a deep and sincere friendship with tribal leaders and worked closely with the Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe.

Demonstrating a lifelong dedication to historic preservation and profound respect for Native American culture and heritage, Melanie requested that, upon her death, memorials be made to the Mashpee Wampanoag Youth Scholarship Program. Through this program, a scholarship was awarded to a Mashpee Wampanoag youth in her honor.

Her MMS colleagues drafted the touching memoriam (below) that was included in the bureau’s Ocean Science publication.

Archaeologists aren’t afraid to get dirty. Melanie is second from the left in the tug-of-war at an MMS employees picnic. photo credit: Keith Good

Read Full Post »

In September, Vineyard Wind and GE Vernova announced “an amicable settlement” to resolve litigation regarding the Vineyard Wind project. The terms of the agreement are confidential, so we won’t know the extent to which financial arrangements factored into the settlement.

The parties may publicly be singing “Kumbaya,” but that doesn’t dismiss the serious allegations. Unresolved data falsification charges, including the following Vineyard Wind allegation, are particularly troubling:

“This exceptional misconduct includes [GE Vernova’s] intentional scheme to falsify critical quality assurance data… and to intentionally misrepresent the quality of those blades to [Vineyard Wind] in a brazen fraudulent, and willful breach of the TSA [Turbine Supply and Service and Maintenance Agreements], ultimately resulting in the catastrophic blade failure…”

Data falsification, was also reported by Radio Gaspesie in Quebec. If the allegations are true, serious violations of Federal regulations were committed, and both GE Vernova and Vineyard Wind may be subject to civil and criminal penalties.

Civil penalties are administered by MMA, Criminal penalties, administered by the Justice Dept, could be warranted if the falsification of quality assurance data is confirmed. The relevant text from the statute is pasted below.

We also have the outstanding matter of the waived Fabrication and Installation Report (FIR) requirement that was granted so the project could stay on schedule. The FIR addresses quality assurance measures, so the waiver is highly relevant and concerning.

Finally, 28 months after the incident, BSEE/MMA has yet to issue an investigation report or share information on their findings. Are penalty issues contributing to the delay?

43 U.S. Code § 1350 – Remedies and penalties – (c) Criminal penalties

Any person who knowingly and willfully (1) violates any provision of this subchapter, any term of a lease, license, or permit issued pursuant to this subchapter, or any regulation or order issued under the authority of this subchapter designed to protect health, safety, or the environment or conserve natural resources, (2) makes any false statement, representation, or certification in any application, record, report, or other document filed or required to be maintained under this subchapter, (3) falsifies, tampers with, or renders inaccurate any monitoring device or method of record required to be maintained under this subchapter, or (4) reveals any data or information required to be kept confidential by this subchapter shall, upon conviction, be punished by a fine of not more than $100,000, or by imprisonment for not more than ten years, or both. Each day that a violation under clause (1) of this subsection continues, or each day that any monitoring device or data recorder remains inoperative or inaccurate because of any activity described in clause (3) of this subsection, shall constitute a separate violation

Read Full Post »

The attached order by Kern County Superior Court Judge Bernard C. Barmann Jr.:

  • Declares the California Geologic Energy Management Division (“CalGEM”) 2021-2024 policy of denying all well stimulation treatment (WST) permit applications invalid.
  • Declares the 2024 Rule (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 14, § 1780, subd. (d)) invalid because CalGEM’s determination that the categorical ban is reasonably necessary is not supported by substantial evidence and lacks a rational connection to the statute’s GHG-reduction purpose.
  • Directs CalGEM to set aside the 2024 Rule and the challenged permit denials; reconsider the denied applications; and consider the pending applications under section 3160 and applicable regulations, without reliance on the invalid underground policy or the invalidated Rule.
  • The Court does not direct issuance of any permit or impose additional denial-letter or deadline requirements.

The ruling could unlock oil resources in in Kern County’s diatomite formations estimated at up to a billion barrels.

Will this decision have any effect on the dispute related to the California Coastal Commission’s prohibition against the resumption of hydraulic well stimulation at Platform Gilda?

Read Full Post »

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit has not yet ruled on the merits of the challenge to PHMSA’s assertion of exclusive Federal jurisdiction over Sable Offshore Corp.’s Las Flores (Santa Ynez) pipeline segments (CA-324 and CA-325) or related restart approvals. A three-judge panel ordered additional briefing after a status conference, and a decision is expected to take months.

The 9th Circuit panel held a video status conference on 10/5/2026, and consolidated petitions from the Environmental Defense Center (and other groups) and the State of California. The panel ordered further briefing rather than issuing an immediate decision on the core jurisdictional question—whether the onshore pipeline segments engage in “interstate commerce” under the Pipeline Safety Act (making them subject to exclusive PHMSA authority rather than California’s Office of the State Fire Marshal).

Concise background summary from Grok: PHMSA reclassified the pipelines as interstate in late 2025 (asserting jurisdiction because they transport crude from Outer Continental Shelf platforms through California to a Kern County terminal, with arguments that onshore processing does not break the flow of interstate commerce). This enabled restart approvals and special permits (initially emergency, later a longer-term one) that environmental groups and California challenge as unlawful, preemptive of state authority, and deficient under the Pipeline Safety Act, NEPA, and ESA. Sable restarted operations earlier in 2026 amid related litigation (including Defense Production Act issues and consent-decree matters in district court). The Ninth Circuit cases are Environmental Defense Center et al. v. PHMSA (No. 25-8059) and the consolidated California petition (originally No. 26-508 / related Nos.).

Read Full Post »

Comments on the proposed “Revisions to the Requirements for Exploratory Drilling on the Arctic Outer Continental Shelf” are due today.

My submission (one page) is attached. Main points:

  • Removing the same-season-relief-well (SSRW) requirements is an essential precursor to the renewal of arctic drilling activity. The SSRW provisions make Arctic operations cost prohibitive while at the same time increasing safety and environmental risks.
  • The potential risks and benefits of a subsea isolation device (SSID) should be assessed on a case-by-case basis considering water depth, temperature related BOP failure risks, wellhead integration, ice and vessel traffic exposure, and other factors.
  • As is the case for floating drilling operations anywhere, the focus in the Arctic should be on well design, integrity, and control, including carefully verifying casing and cement integrity, ensuring complete barrier redundancy, and having standby capping and containment capability.

Read Full Post »

Sable’s update includes production and sales information, but nothing about the pipeline anomalies. Summary:

  • Platform Hondo modernization and operational commissioning are complete. (Hondo is the last of the 3 platforms to come online.)
  • Sable anticipates Federal (MMA) approval of the Platform Hondo instrumentation, control, and safety commissioning this month.
  • Each of Hondo’s 9 perforation additions (Perf Adds) are expected to add ~600 barrels of oil per day to the base well production at a cost of approximately $800,000 per operation.
  • Completing the Los Flores Canyon (LFC) operational and facility upgrades ahead of the restart of Platform Hondo is expected to allow the flow of all SYU wells, maintain continuous operations and reduce downtime in Q4 2026.
  • Sable’s preliminary estimate of oil sales during the months of July and August is approximately 32 thousand gross barrels of oil per day averaged over the two months, with September oil sales volumes expected to be approximately 34 thousand gross barrels of oil per day.
  • Sable is working with midstream and downstream partners to alleviate third party sales constraints experienced in the second half of August and September 2026. (This is presumably why July/Aug sales were lower than previously forecast.)
  • Nominations to Sable’s crude purchaser are expected to increase to an average of 38 thousand gross barrels of oil per day in October 2026. An October 2026 estimated exit rate of approximately 45 thousand bopd prior to the expected addition of Hondo volumes.
  • Sable expects increasing oil sales rates after this month.

Also Sable related:

Read Full Post »

I asked two AI wizards if they could tell me the total number of lawsuits filed against Sable Offshore or the Federal govt regarding the restart and transport of production from the Santa Ynez Unit. One said the total fluctuates as new petitions are filed and consolidated. (Duh! 😉)

Grok gave it a good shot, qualifying the answer as appropriate:

“There is no single official or comprehensive public tally of every lawsuit ever filed on this topic. As of late September 2026, reporting describes roughly a dozen active/related lawsuits tied to the Santa Ynez Unit (SYU) pipelines and restart; many more have been filed overall (some resolved, consolidated, or mooted).” (Reasonable answer.)

The most recent Court filing is by a group of NGOs challenging PHMSA’s June 25, 2026, order granting a “Special Permit” to Sable Offshore. The Special Permit, which is the subject of a number of lawsuits pertinent to the restart of Santa Ynez Unit production, applies to onshore pipeline segments CA-324 and CA-325. The pipeline originates at Las Flores Canyon in Santa Barbara County and terminates at Pentland Station in Kern County (map above).

In brief, the petitioners claim that the Special Permit and related documents were issued in excess of PHMSA’s statutory jurisdiction and authority and were issued unlawfully, and that PHMSA’s conclusions are arbitrary, capricious, and an abuse of discretion. Petitioners also challenge FWS’s concurrence with PHMSA’s determination that its order(s) will not likely adversely affect endangered species.

Here is a link to the complete Court filing, courtesy of Politico. For those who are following these matters, the PHMSA permit and related documents are included as exhibits. This compilation is helpful.

Read Full Post »

Kudos to EPA for their Notice (attached) informing that carbon capture and sequestration (CCS) doesn’t meet the Clean Air Act’s definition of “best system of emissions reduction” (BSER). This common sense determination is a setback for companies chasing the generous 45Q tax credits that their lobbyists succeeded in retaining and enhancing in the One Big Beautiful Bill (table below).

Per the Notice: “EPA is finalizing the determination that 90 percent CCS is not the BSER for existing long-term coal-fired steam generating units because 90 percent CCS has not been adequately demonstrated, the costs of 90 percent CCS are not reasonable, and the associated degree of emission limitation is not achievable.”

EPA further determined “that previous projects that failed to achieve 90 percent CCS were not a sufficient basis to conclude the technology has been adequately demonstrated. Additionally, the carbon dioxide (CO2) capture, pipeline, and sequestration infrastructure necessary to implement 90 percent CCS for the fleet of existing coal-fired steam generating units does not currently exist and would need to be broadly deployed.“

EPA sensibly concludes (p. 58969) that the 45Q tax credit should NOT be accounted for when evaluating the reasonableness of the costs of the BSER. The carbon disposal industry has discounted the risks and overstated the benefits of CCS in their pursuit of those tax benefits, on which that industry is dependent.

Meanwhile. the Texas Railroad Commission by a 2-1 vote just approved a major carbon disposal project despite strong local opposition. The Rose Project will dispose of 53 million metric tons of carbon dioxide ($4.5 billion in tax credits).

Extension of the carbon disposal industry to Federal offshore waters appears to have failed. Only 7 of the 163 OCS oil and gas leases wrongfully acquired by Exxon and Repsol for carbon disposal purposes remain in effect. Those 7 leases will probably be relinquished before they expire in 2027.

199 oil and gas leases were wrongfully acquired for carbon disposal purposes. at Sales, 257, 259, and 261. Those blocks (red and blue) are adjacent to Texas waters. Only 7 of those leases remain in effect.

Read Full Post »

Inline inspections identified anomalies at multiple points in Segment 324 of Sable’s onshore pipeline. Sable is conducting validation digs.(Noozhawk image).

Sable Offshore has asked Santa Barbara County for approval to conduct exploratory digs to check anomalies at seven points along onshore Segment 324 of the Santa Ynez Unit pipeline system. This 10.86 mile segment runs from the Los Flores Canyon Processing Facility to the Gaviota Pump Station (map below).

According to the Emergency Special Permit issued by PHMSA, Sable is required to conduct in-line inspections (ILIs) with metal loss tools every 6 months for the first 2 years of operation.

Where metal loss is identified, immediate repair is required if the remaining strength of pipe shows a predicted failure pressure <1.39 times the maximum operating pressure (MOP).

Where direct field examinations indicate pipe wall loss of 40% or more, permanent repairs are required.

Comments:

Read Full Post »

As expected, the Santa Barbara County Board of Supervisors voted 3-2 to ban new onshore oil and gas drilling. This is another example of the South County (Districts 1-3) majority voting to deny the rights of North County (Districts 4 and 5) property owners and workers. Keep in mind that oil has been produced in the County for more than 130 years.

Attached is a concise, powerful comment letter submitted to the Board by Californians for Property Rights. Excerpt (emphasis added):

“Property rights are key to our nation’s prosperity, and these rights have been shown to be foundational to building prosperity around the world. However, for Americans, these rights are not only integral to our economy but also, and even more importantly, to our Constitution.
Oil and gas mineral and royalty interests are private property. Minerals cannot be moved when government changes the rules. Their value depends upon the ability to access and responsibly produce them, and a government prohibition can effectively eliminate that value.
These impacts reach real families. Mineral and royalty income supports farmers, ranchers, retirees, small businesses, and other property owners. For some agricultural families, it helps keep working farms and ranches economically viable and in family ownership.”

Related constitutionality issues:

  • In July, the National Assoc. of Royalty Owners sent the Board a legal opinion challenging the constitutionality of such ordinances. NARO also sent a comment letter to the Board prior to their vote.
  • A suit filed by John and Melinda Morgan, who inherited the mineral rights to two parcels in the Cat Canyon Field (District 4). argues that a similar provision in CA Senate Bill 1137 amounts to an unconstitutional taking of their property.
  • California AB 1448 would limit the property rights of Federal lessees and deprive royalty owners – most notably the citizens of the United States – of revenue.

Read Full Post »

Older Posts »