Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Posts Tagged ‘pipeline repair’

John Smith comments on the Coastal Commission’s Staff Report on the Sable Cease and Desist Order

Posted in California, energy policy, Offshore Energy - General, Regulation, tagged , , , , , , on April 9, 2025| Leave a Comment »

BOE contributor John Smith has shared (attached) his highlighted version of the 89 page California Coastal Commission staff report recommending imposition of a $15 million fine. 

John finds it noteworthy that the report documents that Santa Barbara County did not concur with the CCC, and that the California State Lands Commission approved the span remediation work. John thinks this raises legitimate questions as to whether the CCC is overreaching in terms of asserting permitting authority for the repair and maintenance work. 

John thinks it will be interesting to see how the Courts rule on this and expects an appeal regardless of the outcome. He points to the Court ruling against the CCC on Pismo Beach offroading case as being pertinent to the Sable-CCC dispute. (“Is the Friends of Oceano Dunes court victory a good omen for Sable?“)

In particular, note the text John has highlighted in green. These issues will likely be central to the Court deliberations.

CCC Staff Report -$15 Million Penalty 032825Download

Read Full Post »

California Coastal Commission to Sable: How dare you!

Posted in California, Offshore Energy - General, tagged , , , , , , on October 15, 2024| Leave a Comment »

The California Coastal Commission, which exercises enormous power and limited restraint, is making headlines for preventing SpaceX, arguably America’s most extraordinary company, from increasing the number of satellite launches from the Vandenberg Space Force Base, a Federal facility. The Coastal Commission made this decision just 3 days before SpaceX’s awe inspiring rocket booster catch in Texas:

Sable Offshore, despite being spawned by super-major Exxon, is a relative minnow compared to SpaceX, at least politically. The restart of production from Sable’s Santa Ynez Unit is facing another obstacle now that the Coastal Commission has entered the fray.

The Coastal Commission has ordered Sable to stop the installation of pipeline shutdown valves that are not only prudent, but required by the California Fire Marshall, the State’s safety authority for pipelines. The Commission has intervened by asserting that the pipeline upgrades require a coastal development permit.

Sable argues that repair and maintenance activities are exempt from Coastal Act permitting requirements, and have been conducted under their existing permits for 35+ years.

The Commission does not like to see its authority questioned, and is influenced by groups whose sole objective is to prevent the restart of production. We’ll see how this sorts out.

Center for Biological Diversity photo of pipeline repair work as published by Noozhawk

Meanwhile, Elon Musk did not hold back after the Commission’s decision not to allow an increase in the number of launches from Vandenberg:

“The California Coastal Commission should be dissolved as an organization.  An utterly insufferable and misanthropic group of Karens if there ever was one! Their idea of the perfect coastline is one where there are zero humans or even signs of human! Anyone who has had any dealings with them will attest to this.  They should not exist.”

Ouch! Tell us what you really think Elon! 😉

Read Full Post »