Bud's Offshore Energy (BOE)

Like mowing a 40 acre field with a 1/4 inch lawn mower. ~ Ed Tennyson, 1989

Reading today’s transcript reminded me of my colleague Ed Tennyson’s famous comment about the response to the Valdez spill in Prince William Sound, Alaska.  Ed’s comment, which appeared on the front page of the Wall Street Journal, was typically colorful and fitting.  A media darling, Ed was given a time-out for that one, but rebounded nicely.

I’m not suggesting that the Montara spill and response were a mismatch of Valdez proportions.  The Montara responders seemed to be competent and made reasonable decisions.  However, the testimony does suggest the need for some improvements in the response regime.  A few observations:

1. There appears to be a need to clarify responsibilities and liability limits for studies and damages.  Also, consideration should be given to an oil spill trust fund (paid for by a per barrel production and transportation fee) to cover any additional authorized costs.
2. It seems that all of the slick monitoring was visual.  Mr. Berger is right in alleging that there are now more accurate methods.  AMSA should investigate  aerial slick mapping and thickness measurement capabilities.
3. It seems at least one Federal agency did not step up and provide requested assistance during the crisis.  Further explanation is necessary.
4. When a well is blowing out, you shouldn’t rely solely on slick data to estimate the spill rate.  PTTEP should have used reservoir and well design data to model the flow and estimate the spillage rate.

Howe (Commission): I have been absolutely struck by the technology and the accuracy of the transcript and the promptness with which it comes up

Amen to that; great job by the recorders!